How to Romance Your Woman

Her Love Language,
Without The Quiz

She's been telling you which one it is for years, in three ordinary ways, and none of them require her to sit down and fill out a questionnaire about herself.

A stoneware mug of tea still steaming on a painted windowsill beside a folded pair of tortoiseshell reading glasses, low golden morning sun coming through the glass

You know the phrase. It came up at a dinner, or it turned up under something she sent you, and the idea underneath it made sense right away: people register love in different forms, and it's possible to spend twenty years paying into a form your wife doesn't count.

Then the next thing anybody hands you is a quiz. An online questionnaire, and it wants her to take one too.

If something about that doesn't sit right, you're not being stubborn. A questionnaire asks your wife to describe herself in the abstract, on a Tuesday evening, in a mood that has nothing to do with the question. You have better data than that sitting in the last three years of your own kitchen.

Three things tell you which language is hers, and all three are already happening in your house. How to read them, one thing to do about each of the five languages once you have your answer, and how to check that answer with her without turning it into a project.

Aim Chapman's Three Questions At Her Instead

In The 5 Love Languages, Gary Chapman, a marriage counselor, sorts the ways a person registers love into five categories: words of affirmation, quality time, receiving gifts, acts of service, and physical touch.

The five categories come out of one counselor's pattern across many years of clients, not out of a validated instrument, and every diagnostic in the book is people describing themselves. Treat the number five and the exact borders between the categories as one practitioner's map rather than a measured finding. What's underneath it costs nothing to test at your own kitchen table.

Late in the book Chapman offers a way to name your own:

I have suggested three ways to discover your own primary love language:

Your own. All three questions are written for a reader trying to figure out himself. Turned around and aimed at your wife, they work the same way, with one honest difference: pointed at yourself you're remembering, and pointed at her you're guessing. She's the only one who can confirm the guess, and there's a way to let her do that without it becoming a whole conversation.

You also won't see much of any of this while the two of you are side by side facing a television. That's part of why I sell what I sell: Date Nights Dancing is a dance program you run in your own living room, the two of you facing each other instead of pointed at the same screen.

1. Start With The Complaint You Like Least

The thing she raises most often, the one you have an answer ready for before she finishes it, is the most useful sentence in your marriage right now. Chapman puts it this way:

Your complaints reveal your inner desires. (If you have difficulty remembering what you complain about most often, ask your wife. She’ll know.)

He's writing to a man about his own complaints there. Run it the other direction and listen to hers.

Chapman's own examples of how it sounds: she says the two of you never spend time together, and that's quality time. Or she asks why you didn't bring anything back from your trip, which is gifts. Or you get told you'd never touch her if she didn't start it. That one is physical touch.

One filter. A complaint that tracks a hard week is about the week. You're after the one that's been showing up for years in slightly different words, because that one is a pattern and not a mood.

2. Notice What She Hands You Without Being Asked

Chapman's version of this one:

In what way do you regularly express love to your spouse? Your method of expressing love may be an indication that that would also make you feel loved.

People tend to give in whatever currency they'd want back. So look at what she does for you that nobody asked her to do, over and over, for no occasion. The coffee already poured when you come down. The card she writes to your mother every year. Her hand on your back walking through a parking lot.

Chapman hedges this one himself, and the hedge is right there in the sentence: may be an indication. Use it to break a tie between two readings you're stuck on. Don't let it make the call by itself.

3. Count What She Asks For Twice

Chapman again, on what gets asked for:

Whatever you have most requested is probably in keeping with your primary love language.

A single ask is a task. The same ask twice, months apart, in different words, is a language. Can we go somewhere, just the two of us, in March. We never do anything anymore, in July. Those are one request. The months in between are what turn it from a task into a pattern.

This overlaps with the complaint you started with, and that overlap is fine. A request is what the complaint sounded like before it went sour. If you hear the same content in both, you're almost certainly right.

Five Languages, And What To Do About Each One This Week

One thing per language, none of it requiring a purchase or a free evening.

1. Words Of Affirmation: Name The Scene, Not The Trait

Say back a specific thing you saw her do. Generic praise is easy to produce and easy to discount. "You're so good with them" is too broad to count. The dinner she put together Thursday out of a half-empty fridge, said back to her with the fridge in the sentence, counts. If words turn out to be hers, there's a whole piece on what to say to make her feel special.

2. Quality Time: Turn The Television Off For Fifteen Minutes

Chapman means undivided attention, not shared square footage. Being on the same couch with the television running is not it. Fifteen minutes with the television off, both of you doing one thing and talking while you do it, is. The Date Nights Dancing program is my version of that fifteen minutes: easy swing taught at home, both of you on the same moves from the first video, no studio and no dance experience required. If dancing isn't where you want to start, the date night ideas here are sorted by situation.

3. Receiving Gifts: Buy The Small Thing She Mentioned Once

Chapman is clear that the cost barely matters unless it's out of line with what you can afford. The gift works as proof that you were thinking about her when she wasn't in the room. Which means the small thing on an ordinary Wednesday beats the expensive thing bought on the date a gift was expected. Buy the tea she mentioned once and never bought herself.

4. Acts Of Service: Ask Her Which Three

More chores isn't the answer, and you're probably already doing plenty of them. Ask her for three specific ones. Chapman likes written lists for exactly this reason: they force people to get concrete, and the concrete version is almost never the version you'd have guessed. If you want a structure for a full month of this, that's what the kindness challenge is built for.

5. Physical Touch: Reach For Her When Nothing Comes Next

The touch that fills this one is mostly the non-sexual kind, distributed through an ordinary day: a hand on her back in the kitchen, holding hands from the car into the store, reaching for her when other people are in the room. A slow song in the living room is about four minutes of it at once, and how to slow dance with your wife covers the whole of what that takes.

Then Check Your Read With Her

Chapman says the obvious thing about all of this, and he says it in the touch chapter where it matters most:

Your best instructor is your spouse, of course.

So don't present her with your findings. There's no version of "I've been observing you for three weeks" that improves an evening.

Two better options. Act on your read for a couple of weeks and pay attention to what comes back. Or ask her directly, with none of the framework attached, in an ordinary minute rather than a serious one: what's one small thing I do that makes you feel loved? Ask for a small one on purpose. A big answer is a compliment. A small one is an instruction.

Either way you'll know inside a month or two whether you read her right. What you might notice is that the request she used to make twice stops coming up as often, on the same amount of effort you were already spending.

And if what you get back is that she doesn't feel it much lately even though you've been carrying a lot, the gap between doing and feeling loved has its own piece here: why real effort can register as nothing.

Tell Her Which One Is Yours

This runs both directions, and your half is the half that gets skipped.

If you provide hard and you've never told your wife what would mean something to you, partly because saying it feels like asking to be thanked for doing your job: say it anyway at some point. Plainly, not in the same conversation as any of the rest of this, so it doesn't read as a trade.

And if your read comes back wrong, you're not out anything. Three weeks of paying close attention to your wife is a good use of three weeks, whichever of the five you should have been paying into.

One good idea, every Thursday

The Thursday reminder over 100,000 couples love: ideas and conversation starters that deepen love, laughter, and intimacy.

You're in. Check your inbox Thursday.
Keep dancin' & romancin'